scribblemyname: (dreamers: roswell)
[personal profile] scribblemyname
This entry is part 44 of 51 in the series 365 Challenge

Gacked from penknife:

You post a topic, list, category, whatever, in comments. (examples: "Five SG-1 Mission Reports That Were Less Than Entirely Truthful", or "Five Times Bruce Banner Lost His Toothbrush," or "Five Ways Nikola Tesla Failed to Take Over the World"). I'll answer with a list of five things.

Ideally fandoms that I know something about, unless you want me to guess, which could be entertaining but probably not the way you want. Or (and preferably) original fiction. All storyworlds on the table, i.e. Seven Days, Kingdoms and Thorn, the Alliance, Vardin, etc.


Completed Ficlets & Scenes

Kingdoms and Thorn:

Originally published at Liana Mir. You can comment here or there.

From: [identity profile] thecatisacritic.livejournal.com
I'm a bit confused by the last bit... Exactly what does this immunity mean?

I wonder how betrayed Marc feels about learning there are secondary abilities he doesn't know about with the people he works with.

From: [identity profile] thecatisacritic.livejournal.com
Ah. Okay. Thanks for clarifying.

:) Ha ha. More prompts.
From: [identity profile] thecatisacritic.livejournal.com
So... I guess I was expecting more of a reaction.

It's like when Shift handled that moment when Justus met Red Wolf. It's not bad, I liked the story. It's an interesting perspective and dynamic, but I still didn't see the thoughts of the person I was expecting. I get Cate's thoughts, not Marc's. I still know nothing about him. And for some reason, I came off not liking Cate very much after this.
From: [identity profile] thecatisacritic.livejournal.com
I wasn't expecting you to do this one for a bit, and it probably would have been better if I'd gotten their long fics first. I didn't get that sense about her, that she was enjoying not reading him. It was hinted at, but I didn't really understand the hint. So her teasing didn't seem... appropriate.

I admit, I'm not sure I want in his head, but I would think the reaction needs to come from him.
Edited Date: 2013-09-17 01:55 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] thecatisacritic.livejournal.com
I think sometimes with me, it's like walking a minefield, never knowing what might set me off.

This one I read it the second time after getting off a bad day at work and my overwhelming reaction to it was a very frustrated, "why am I getting Cate's thoughts on this when I asked what Marc felt? This was supposed to be how he felt about that world changer, and I didn't see that at all."

Exaggeration, of course, because if I look in there, it's there, but I had to go back and look for it.

Add in my lack of familiarity with these two, not understanding them or their dynamic, I had thought learning something like that would be a much greater betrayal than it seemed to be. Her teasing him in that case would have been inappropriate, and I also felt like the part when she was watching his eyes was rather school girlish and out of place, too.

We discussed how I tend to feel about people who use smiles/laughter as coping mechanisms, and I think it is a very thin line for me between when they are using that and when they come off as jerks and liars. It's a personal bias, going back to me always thinking it was a lie if I said I was okay when I was depressed.

*sigh*

Because of all that, her teasing in the first one seemed smug, maybe even... bitchy. She read to me like she didn't care what she'd done in disrupting his world. The way she was just like "you already knew" rubbed me the wrong way.

With the second one, he wasn't subtle about explaining her reactions. I understood her teasing him in the second one. I saw him react, and he expected that from her. It still wasn't what I expected as a sense of betrayal, but that wasn't what it was to him, just what I expected it to be.
From: [identity profile] thecatisacritic.livejournal.com
Well, you can't go altering your style just for me. I wish I was better at the subtle... I don't understand why I need things to hit me like a brick. It makes me feel stupid, and I'm not, and I'd blame it on my reading being too fast, but I have good retention of what I read. I just seem to struggle with getting it.
From: [identity profile] thecatisacritic.livejournal.com
It has felt kind of like I need a brick lately.

How many times do I ask for clarification on a given piece or part of the story world?
From: [identity profile] thecatisacritic.livejournal.com
Yeah... I don't think I could share any of the beta notes I've ever gotten. I'd be too ashamed because usually I get notes when I do stuff that's really dumb.

From: [identity profile] thecatisacritic.livejournal.com
I do like this a lot better from his perspective.

It managed to give his thoughts and also show depth to her as well.

From: [identity profile] thecatisacritic.livejournal.com
The clarity helps. Sometimes the insider is too far inside, and they need someone else to bring it out for them.

I think I tend toward putting it in the perspective of the new person. I have been told before that while I know all that's behind the story, the characters and the world, that I share too little of it, so I leave people filling in the blanks, and then they lose track of the story because it's not how they imagined it. So I try and find some angle that gives the explanation, and if there is an outsider who needs it, I jump at the chance for that.

I'm glad this one worked and came together for you and that it was... worth tilting because I said something.
From: [identity profile] in-the-blue.livejournal.com
This is pretty great. My favorite thing about it is how commonplace their work dialog is, how seamlessly it flows. It reads like an everyday discussion: each character has their personality, that's never in question, and they each have their own little triumphs and failures.

I have to say that this might be my favorite world of yours as a reader. You know why? You're not afraid to delve into it headlong and take as long as you need to make sense of it. Sure, it's other-worldly, but it's an orderly yet gripping world. As an author you seem to know it with this finesse and intimacy and as a reader, I appreciate that so much.

I got it about the immunity, by the way.

Profile

scribblemyname: (Default)
scribblemyname

July 2024

S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
1415 1617181920
21222324252627
28293031   

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Feb. 23rd, 2026 04:55 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios